MetLife Long-Term Disability Insurance Denial

Understanding MetLife Disability Claim Denials

Founded in 1868 as Metropolitan Life Insurance Company, MetLife has grown into one of the top providers of employer-sponsored group long-term disability coverage. Millions of Americans depend on the company to pay up when illness or injury forces them out of work.

However, MetLife's track record shows a pattern of disputed denials and regulatory scrutiny. The company has faced federal investigations, class action lawsuits, and court decisions criticizing how they handle claims.

Key facts about MetLife disability insurance denials:

• Like all insurance companies, MetLife has a legal duty to act in good faith toward their policyholders. That duty requires the company to evaluate claims fairly, apply policy terms reasonably, and pay legitimate claims without unnecessary delay.
• MetLife denies long-term disability claims for various reasons, and not all of them are valid. The insurer uses tactics to limit payouts, many of which have been successfully challenged in court.
• When MetLife ignores medical evidence, relies on biased paper reviews, or uses paperwork technicalities to deny valid claims, they may be acting in bad faith — and policyholders have the right to fight back.
• MetLife stopped selling individual disability policies and now focuses exclusively on group coverage, almost all of which falls under the Employment Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA).
• MetLife has faced lawsuits involving the improper use of surveillance, biased paper reviews, and misuse of Social Security death databases.
• The Better Business Bureau has received such a high volume of complaints about MetLife that they only publish 1 out of every 5 complaints.

MetLife is one of the largest group disability insurers in the country. If MetLife denied your long-term disability claim, you're up against a company with nearly $50 Billion in net worth, thousands of employees, and a legal team built to protect their bottom line.

An experienced MetLife long-term disability attorney at Sokolove Law can help families in all 50 states understand their rights and fight for the benefits they're entitled to.

5 Reasons for a MetLife Disability Denial

MetLife disability claims are often denied due to insufficient medical evidence, failure to meet the policy's definition of disability, or missed documentation deadlines.

Other frequent reasons include the shift from "own occupation" to "any occupation," surveillance activity, and policy limitations on mental health or self-reported conditions.

The 5 most common reasons for a MetLife disability denial include:

• Insufficient Medical Evidence: Even with a confirmed diagnosis, MetLife can deny a claim if your records don't specifically document what you cannot do. Medical conditions like chronic pain, fatigue, migraines, fibromyalgia, and mental health disorders are especially vulnerable because they rely on subjective reporting.
• Failure to Meet Policy Definitions: For the first 24 months, disability may be defined as the inability to perform your own occupation. After 24 months, the definition shifts to the inability to perform any occupation. This transition is one of MetLife's most common triggers for terminating benefits.
• Procedural and Administrative Errors: MetLife can deny claims on procedural grounds. Missing a deadline to submit updated medical records or file an appeal can result in automatic denial. Policyholders have also reported MetLife claiming not to have received documentation that was submitted.
• Surveillance and Social Media Monitoring: MetLife has been accused of using personal video surveillance and social media monitoring to build cases against claimants, even if that snapshot represents an exceptional day rather than a typical one.
• Policy Limitations on Mental Health Conditions: Many MetLife LTD policies include specific limitations on benefits for mental health conditions, including anxiety and depression, capping payments at 24 months regardless of severity.

A combination of these tactics may be used to justify a MetLife disability claim denial. The goal is to get you to just give up instead of pushing forward with an appeal or legal action.

By understanding the claims handling tactics that insurance companies like MetLife rely on and countering them, the MetLife disability insurance lawyers at Sokolove Law can help you fight back.

What to Do after a MetLife Long-Term Disability Denial

A MetLife long-term disability denial can feel like the end of the road, but it doesn't have to be. Under ERISA, you have the right to appeal MetLife's decision and, if the appeal is denied, to take legal action in federal court.

You typically have 180 days under ERISA to file an appeal. By requesting your claim file, reviewing the reasons for denial, and consulting a disability attorney, you'll be able to strengthen your claim for benefits.

If you're facing a MetLife LTD denial, we may be able to help you:

• Review Your Denial Letter: MetLife is required to send you a written denial letter explaining why your claim was denied and when your appeal deadline expires. This language is often technical, but we can help you cut through the jargon and identify weaknesses in MetLife's reasoning.
• Request Your Complete Claim File: Under ERISA, you have the right to a full copy of your claim file, which often contains valuable information on gaps that can be directly addressed in an appeal.
• Gather Missing Documentation: If MetLife's denial cited a lack of medical evidence, your response needs to directly address those holes. This means updated records from treating physicians, detailed statements about your functional limitations, specialist opinions, and a Functional Capacity Evaluation documenting the tasks you can't perform.
• Meet the 180-Day Deadline: Under ERISA, most policyholders have 180 days from the date of denial to submit a written appeal to MetLife. Missing this deadline can permanently forfeit your right to benefits.
• Even the Playing Field: MetLife has teams of attorneys whose job is to defend their claim decisions. Our MetLife disability appeal attorneys can manage the entire process of gathering evidence, meeting deadlines, drafting the appeal, and filing a lawsuit if the appeal is denied.

Our long-term disability denial lawyers help families nationwide and never charge upfront costs or hourly fees. To date, we've secured over $146 Million total for clients unjustly denied LTD benefits.

“Thanks to Sokolove Law, we won the battle against the insurance company. Now, I have the support and financial security I need to focus on my health and well-being. I’m grateful for their help and would recommend Sokolove Law to anyone facing a similar struggle.”
– Engineer in D.C. with a Denied Disability Claim

What to Expect with a MetLife Disability Appeal

If you're facing a MetLife disability claim denial, you generally have 180 days from the date of the denial letter to submit a written appeal. Because this is typically your final opportunity to add evidence to the record, it's important to take a strategic approach.

The MetLife disability appeal process typically includes:

• Reviewing Your Denial Letter: Identifying the reasons for the denial and confirming your appeal deadline.
• Gathering Additional Evidence: Collecting updated medical records, vocational assessments, physician statements, and other documentation that support your claim.
• Preparing a MetLife Disability Appeal: Addressing MetLife's reasons for denial and explaining why you meet the policy's definition of disability.
• Submitting Your Appeal: Filing your MetLife long-term disability insurance appeal by mail, fax, or other approved methods before the deadline.
• Waiting for a Decision: Under ERISA guidelines, MetLife generally has 45 days to review your appeal, with the option to extend the review period by an additional 45 days in certain circumstances.
• Receiving a Decision: If your MetLife long-term disability insurance appeal is approved, your benefits may be reinstated. If your appeal is denied, you may be able to pursue legal action through a lawsuit against MetLife.

If your MetLife disability policy is provided through your employer, it is likely governed by ERISA. In most ERISA cases, you cannot submit new evidence after the appeal process ends. The administrative appeal is often your best opportunity to build the strongest possible record.

Because of ERISA's strict deadlines and requirements, many claimants choose to work with an experienced long-term disability attorney. Our MetLife disability denial attorneys can help build the strongest appeal possible.

Who Can File a MetLife Disability Lawsuit?

A MetLife lawsuit may be possible if you've exhausted the company's internal appeals process and were still denied the benefits you're entitled to.

You may be able to file a MetLife disability lawsuit if:

• You were denied long-term disability benefits
• Your MetLife long-term disability insurance appeal was unsuccessful
• MetLife's denial was unreasonable or not supported by the terms of your policy
• You have met the requirements for filing a lawsuit under ERISA or state law

There's only a limited amount of time to take legal action due to statutes of limitations. Once the filing deadline passes, you may lose your right to pursue benefits you deserve.

Steps to File a MetLife Long-Term Disability Lawsuit​

From gathering evidence to meeting strict deadlines, appealing a MetLife disability denial requires following specific procedures. Missing a deadline or failing to submit enough evidence can make it harder to recover benefits.

If you're dealing with a MetLife long-term disability claim denial, it's important to know your deadline, understand the reasons for denial, craft a strong appeal that counters those reasons, and consider filing a MetLife lawsuit if your appeal is unsuccessful.

At Sokolove Law, we help guide clients through every stage of the process, from the initial appeal to a potential MetLife disability lawsuit, providing peace of mind and allowing claimants to focus on their health and family.

1. Know Your Deadline

Most employer-sponsored disability plans governed by ERISA give policyholders 180 days to appeal a denial. Acting quickly gives you more time to gather the evidence needed to support your claim.

Missing this deadline can jeopardize your right to challenge MetLife's decision and may prevent you from pursuing benefits through a MetLife denial lawsuit.

2. Review Your MetLife Disability Policy & Claim File

Your MetLife denial letter and claim file can provide valuable insight into why MetLife denied your claim.

Our MetLife disability appeal lawyers can review:

• The stated reasons for denial
• How your MetLife policy defines disability
• Medical and vocational evidence in your claim file
• Internal reviews conducted by MetLife
• Missing information that could strengthen your appeal

After reviewing these materials, we can develop a strategy tailored to your case. This may include identifying weaknesses in MetLife's decision, obtaining additional medical evidence, and addressing any gaps or inconsistencies in the record.

3. Submit a Comprehensive Appeal

A MetLife disability appeal should directly address each reason for denial and include all available supporting evidence related to your job and qualifying health condition.

Your MetLife disability insurance appeal may include:

• A detailed appeal letter explaining why the denial was incorrect
• Updated medical records and diagnostic testing
• Statements from treating physicians regarding your limitations
• Specialist evaluations and vocational evidence
• Statements from family members, friends, or coworkers describing the impact of your condition

Because federal courts generally cannot consider new evidence after the appeal process ends, it's critical to submit as much supporting documentation as possible during this stage.

4. Wait for a Decision

After receiving your appeal, MetLife will review the information and issue a decision on whether they believe you're entitled to benefits.

Under ERISA guidelines, MetLife typically has 45 days to make a decision, although it may extend the review period for an additional 45 days in certain situations.

Our team can handle communications with MetLife throughout the process and monitor the claim to ensure all deadlines and requirements are met.

5. File a MetLife Denial Lawsuit

If the insurer denies your appeal, you may have the right to file a MetLife disability lawsuit. For most employer-sponsored policies, the lawsuit will be filed under ERISA in federal court and will be decided by a judge based on the evidence submitted during the appeals process.

Insurance companies like MetLife often have extensive legal resources dedicated to defending claim denials. Having an experienced legal team on your side can help level the playing field and improve your chances of recovering benefits.

Our MetLife ERISA lawsuit lawyers can evaluate your claim, explain your legal options, and pursue a lawsuit on your behalf if you qualify.

MetLife Disability Settlements & Verdicts

MetLife disability settlements and verdicts vary based on the facts of each case. Factors like the strength of your medical evidence, the terms of your policy, and the reason for the denial can all affect the outcome.

In some cases, claimants may recover past-due benefits dating back to the original denial, as well as interest and, in certain situations, bad faith penalties.

MetLife disability settlements and verdicts secured by our team include:

• $305,000 for a California portfolio manager with migraines
• $225,000 for a Texas man facing a MetLife long-term disability denial
• $100,000 for a California woman who was denied benefits after MetLife's independent doctors determined she was well enough to work after 3 years of not working
• $175,000 for an Idaho man with stage 3 cancer
• $165,000 for a California man with an approved disability who was denied for making too much money
• $125,000 for an Oregon woman facing a denial after MetLife decided she could work
• $125,000 for a California woman with musculoskeletal issues
• $149,000 for a North Carolina man who suffered a stroke and was on disability for 2 years when denied
• $106,000 for a California woman denied MetLife benefits even though doctors found she was unable to return to work
• $200,000 for a California woman wrongfully denied MetLife disability

While there's never a guarantee of compensation, our MetLife disability insurance lawyers will fight for the benefits you're entitled to.

MetLife Long-Term Disability Complaints

MetLife policyholders have raised concerns about how the company evaluates and administers disability claims, including allegations of delays, claim denials, and communication issues.

Complaints documented through ConsumerAffairs reviews, Better Business Bureau filings, and federal court cases describe challenges that some claimants say made it more difficult to obtain the benefits they believed they were owed.

Here are 5 common MetLife disability complaints:

• The definition of "disabled" shifts when it's time to pay: Policyholders have reported that MetLife interpreted their policy's disability definition in ways that felt inconsistent with what they understood when they enrolled.
• Physical disabilities reclassified as mental health conditions: Many MetLife policies limit benefits for mental health conditions to 24 months. When a claimant has a physical illness that has caused depression or anxiety, MetLife may attempt to characterize the disability as primarily mental health-driven in order to cut off benefits.
• Benefits terminated at the 2-year mark: MetLife typically intensifies their review in the months leading up to the 2-year mark, terminating benefits that had previously been paid.
• Denials based on doctors who never examined you: MetLife often pays third-party vendors to hire doctors known as "peer reviewers" who review medical records without ever seeing the claimant in person.
• Surveillance footage taken out of context: MetLife has been accused of exploiting surveillance footage to minimize or terminate valid claims.

Better Business Bureau complaints and ConsumerAffairs reviews most often reference unreturned phone calls and denial reasons that seem to change after the claimant pushes back.

The Better Business Bureau has received such a high volume of Metlife disability insurance complaints that they only publish 1 out of every 5 complaints, meaning that the cases that appear publicly are just the surface of a much larger problem.

How Our MetLife Disability Appeal Attorney​s Can Help

MetLife disability claims are often denied based on paper medical reviews, surveillance footage, vocational assessments, or interpretations of policy language that may not tell the full story of your condition.

Our MetLife disability appeal attorneys know how to challenge these tactics and build a stronger claim for benefits.

When handling a MetLife disability appeal, our team may be able to:

• Review the Evidence MetLife Relied On: We can obtain and analyze your complete claim file, including medical reviews, surveillance reports, vocational assessments, and internal notes that contributed to the denial.
• Challenge Selective Medical Reviews: Courts have criticized MetLife for relying on medical reviewers who discounted evidence from treating physicians. We work to ensure all relevant medical evidence is properly considered.
• Address Improper Surveillance Findings: If MetLife improperly relied on surveillance footage while minimizing medical evidence, we can challenge evidence that does not accurately reflect your ability to work.
• Strengthen Evidence of Functional Limitations: MetLife often focuses on what a claimant can theoretically do rather than how their condition affects them throughout a full workday. We gather medical and vocational evidence that documents your real-world limitations.
• Build the Strongest Possible Administrative Record: Because ERISA lawsuits are generally limited to the evidence submitted during the appeal process, we work to ensure your record is as complete as possible before MetLife issues their final decision.
• Prepare for a MetLife Disability Lawsuit If Necessary: If MetLife denies your appeal, we can evaluate whether legal action may be appropriate and pursue the benefits you deserve.

The U.S. Supreme Court has recognized that MetLife faces an inherent conflict of interest because they both evaluate disability claims and pay benefits.

Our MetLife disability appeal attorneys understand how courts analyze MetLife's decisions and can develop a strategy designed to address the issues that commonly lead to wrongful denials.

Do I Need a MetLife Disability Denial Lawyer?

MetLife is one of the largest insurance companies in the world, generating more than $77 Billion in annual revenue and operating in over 40 markets worldwide.

When your disability claim is denied, you're often challenging a decision made by a company with extensive financial resources, in-house experts, and outside legal teams dedicated to defending benefit determinations.

Working with a MetLife disability denial lawyer may improve your chances of successfully challenging a large insurance company with extensive resources. While MetLife has teams dedicated to reviewing and defending claim decisions, an experienced disability attorney can level the playing field and fight for what you deserve.

Why Choose Our MetLife Disability Lawyers?

When you're fighting a MetLife disability denial, the law firm you choose matters. You need a team with the resources to take on a major insurance company and the experience to navigate the complex ERISA appeals process.

At Sokolove Law, we've spent more than 45 years helping people stand up to powerful corporations and insurance companies. We understand the financial and emotional toll a disability denial can have on families, and we're committed to making the legal process as stress-free as possible.

Why choose the MetLife disability attorneys at Sokolove Law?

• Over 45 years of experience
• More than $146 Million total secured for disability clients nationwide
• No upfront costs or out-of-pocket fees
• Free, no-obligation case reviews

While MetLife has substantial resources dedicated to evaluating and defending disability claims, you don't have to face the process alone. Our attorneys and legal professionals can help protect your rights and pursue the benefits you're entitled to.

How Much Do MetLife Lawsuit Lawyers Charge?

At Sokolove Law, we handle MetLife disability cases on a contingency-fee basis. That means there are no upfront costs, no hourly attorney fees, and you pay nothing unless we recover compensation on your behalf.

We believe everyone deserves access to experienced legal representation, regardless of their financial situation. That's why we also offer free, no-obligation case evaluations to help you understand your options after a MetLife disability denial.

MetLife Disability Insurance Lawsuit​ News & Updates

MetLife has faced disability insurance lawsuits, appeals, and regulatory scrutiny for years over allegations that they improperly denied or terminated long-term disability benefits.

A few of the latest MetLife disability denial lawsuit updates include:

• The U.S. Supreme Court ruled against MetLife in a landmark disability benefits case.
• A federal judge ruled that MetLife improperly terminated an engineer's LTD disability benefits after discounting evidence related to COVID symptoms.
• A federal court allowed a class action lawsuit against MetLife to move forward after retirees improperly reduced monthly pension payments.
• The insurer agreed to pay a $50 Million MetLife class action lawsuit settlement over the insurer misleading approximately 8.6 million policyholders during the conversion from a mutual company to a publicly traded company.
• A proposed $213.5 Million MetLife settlement resolved claims involving universal life insurance policies originally sold by the insurer, with policyholders alleging excessive charges and fees.

While every claim is different, MetLife lawsuit decisions can provide insight into how judges evaluate disability denials and the evidence needed to overturn them.

U.S. Supreme Court Rules Against MetLife in Landmark Disability Case

In Metropolitan Life Insurance Co. v. Glenn, the U.S. Supreme Court found that judges may consider MetLife's conflict of interest when reviewing benefit denials because the company both evaluates claims and pays benefits.

The case involved a Sears employee who was granted 24 months of LTD benefits following a diagnosis of a heart disorder. However, MetLife later found her capable of performing sedentary work and denied her the benefits.

The Court ultimately upheld a lower court's decision that overturned MetLife's denial after finding problems with how the insurer evaluated medical evidence and Social Security findings.

MetLife Improperly Terminated LTD Benefits to Worker with COVID

In November 2025, a federal district court found that MetLife improperly terminated a claimant's long-term disability benefits after relying heavily on surveillance footage and selective medical reviews.

Medical records showed the engineer was unable to perform his main job duties because of brain fog, cognitive impairments, and fatigue after two bouts with COVID-19.

Judge Monica Ramirez Almadani of the Central District of California found that his self-reported symptoms were “credible” and supported by laboratory testing.

9th Circuit Rules for Employee in LTD Lawsuit Against MetLife

In January 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit ruled in favor of a claimant whose long-term disability benefits had been terminated by MetLife.

The appeals panel found that MetLife had improperly denied a wealth management firm employee’s LTD benefits because the insurer had concluded that she was disabled.

The ruling relied on the 9th Circuit’s “bright-line rule,” which established that individuals who are unable to sit for more than 4 hours in an 8-hour workday are incapable of performing sedentary jobs.

MetLife Class Action Lawsuit for Pension Benefits Moves Forward

In 2024, a federal judge ruled that MetLife must continue defending a class action lawsuit alleging the company underpaid pension benefits by relying on outdated mortality data when calculating annuity payments.

The MetLife class action lawsuit claims that the insurer used actuarial assumptions that resulted in lower monthly pension payments for retirees who selected certain joint-and-survivor annuity options.

In denying MetLife's request to dismiss the case, the judge found that significant factual disputes remain regarding whether the company's mortality assumptions improperly reduced retirees' benefits.

$50 Million Settlement for Class Action Lawsuit Against MetLife Disability

The insurer agreed to a $50 Million MetLife class action lawsuit settlement over claims they had defrauded 8.6 million policyholders when converting from a mutual company in 2000 to a publicly traded one.

The MetLife class action lawsuit was allegedly reached after a New York federal judge ruled that the insurer could introduce a decision by the New York Superintendent of Insurance that had approved the conversion plus disclosure documents MetLife had mailed to their policyholders.

$213.5 Million MetLife Class Action Lawsuit Over Universal Life Insurance Policies

Sun Life Financial reached a proposed $213.5 Million settlement relating to individual universal life insurance policies sold by Metropolitan Life Insurance of Canada in the 1980s and 1990s.

Sun Life had allegedly been collecting fees from policyholders that were originally sold by MetLife. The policies reportedly had limits that Sun Life may have exceeded when they took them over.

How to Find MetLife Long-Term Disability Appeal Attorneys Near You

When looking for a MetLife long-term disability appeal attorney, you don't necessarily need to hire someone located in your city. Because many MetLife long-term disability claims are governed by ERISA, these cases are often handled through federal litigation that can be managed by a national law firm.

Working with a national disability law firm may offer several advantages, including:

• Access to larger legal teams and extensive resources
• Experience handling claims against major insurers like MetLife
• Familiarity with the complex rules governing ERISA appeals

At Sokolove Law, we represent disability claimants nationwide and have more than 45 years of experience helping people take on large insurance companies.

Our team can review your denial, gather supporting evidence, manage communications with MetLife, and guide you through the appeals process from start to finish.

Get Help with Your MetLife Long-Term Disability Appeal

With Sokolove Law, you can focus on your health while we handle the complexities of your MetLife disability appeal.

If you have a case, our team can manage every stage of the appeals process, from reviewing your claim file to gathering evidence and communicating with MetLife on your behalf.

Call (800) 995-1212 right now or fill out our contact form to find out if we may be able to help with your MetLife long-term disability appeal.

MetLife Lawsuit Lawyer FAQs